When purchasing a new car, it’s natural to focus on features like price, color, model, and fuel efficiency, but safety should always take precedence. A recent analysis by iSeeCars has revealed the five most dangerous car brands currently on the road, shedding light on fatal accident rates and potential risks for buyers.
The study analyzed data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for cars from model years 2018 to 2022 involved in crashes resulting in at least one occupant fatality. According to the findings, Tesla leads the list with 5.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles, followed closely by Kia at 5.5, Buick at 4.8, Dodge at 4.4, and Hyundai at 3.9. These numbers reflect both vehicle safety performance and broader challenges like driver behavior and road conditions.
Tesla, known for its cutting-edge technology and driver-assist systems, ironically tops the list. The Model Y and Model S, despite their advanced features, have been identified as particularly dangerous. Karl Brauer, Executive Analyst at iSeeCars, attributes some of the blame to distracted driving, saying that “new cars are safer than they’ve ever been. But these safety features are being countered by distracted driving and higher rates of speed, leading to rising accident and death rates in recent years.”
Tesla’s record has also been marred by a series of recalls in 2024. Over 125,000 vehicles, including the Model S, Model X, Model 3, and Model Y, were recalled due to seat belt warning malfunctions that could increase injury risks during crashes. The highly anticipated Cybertruck also faced issues, with nearly 4,000 units recalled due to a manufacturing defect causing the accelerator pedal to stick, potentially leading to unintended acceleration.
While Tesla is at the forefront of innovation, other brands like Kia and Buick also demonstrate concerning trends. Kia’s fatal accident rate is only slightly lower than Tesla’s, and Buick, despite its reputation for comfort and reliability, ranks third. The data serves as a reminder that flashy features and marketing should not overshadow fundamental safety considerations.
Even with advanced safety technologies such as driver assistance, modern chassis designs, and airbags, the rise in accidents highlights a critical issue: driver behavior. Distracted driving and excessive speeds continue to counteract the benefits of technological advancements, making it imperative for buyers to scrutinize safety records alongside other features when choosing a vehicle.
